Sunday, March 28, 2021

Meiksins Wood. Chapter 5: “The Agrarian Origin of Capitalism”

 Reading guide for The Origin of Capitalism. A Longer View. Meiksins Wood.

Chapter 5: “The Agrarian Origin of Capitalism”


  1. Explain the process of appropriation of the surplus by exploiters, according to Marx. (95) 

  2. Explain the French structure of exploitation: absolutism. (96)

  3. Why, in the capitalist model, we cannot speak of “direct coercion”? (96)

  4. Define capitalism in this context. (97)

  5. Explain the capitalist logic of imperatives. (97) 

  6. Why is the capitalist system in permanent expansion? (97)

  7. Enumerate and explain the main characteristics of England (the “European exception): -State; Infrastructure and communications; London at the center of the national market. (98-99)  

  8. Explain the relation between landlords and tenants. Why did it give origin to what the author calls “competitive production”? (100)

  9. Explain the difference between market rent and customary rent. (101)

  10. What was the situation in France in regards to property rights? (102)

  11. Explain the relationship between a highly productive agriculture and the large wage-labour force in England. (103)

  12. Explain the concepts of improvement and improver in the English agrarian context. (106)

  13. Why did the traditional concepts of land property start being debated at the time? 

  14. Explain the notion of enclosure in the context of the 17th century in England. (108-9)

  15. Explain John Locke’s opinion about unoccupied land (in the context of the theorization of capitalist property). (110). 

  16. Why does the author say that Locke justifies colonial expropriation? (112)

  17. Why does the author say that, according to Locke, the master appropriates the labour of his servant?

  18. Why are the employers of labour called producers, if, in fact, the producers are the workers? (112-3)

  19.  Why does the author say that Locke gives us a theory of property based on capitalist principles?

  20. Connect Locke’s ideas with the notion of private property. (115)

  21. Why does Locke, according to the author, justify slavery? (115)

  22. What is the bourgeois revolution? (118)

Sunday, March 21, 2021

Meiksins Wood. Chapter 4: “Commerce or Capitalism?”

 Reading guide for The Origin of Capitalism. A Longer View. Meiksins Wood. 

Chapter 4: “Commerce or Capitalism?”


  1. Why should the transition from feudalism to capitalism not be treated as a general European process? (73)

  2. Why is this treatment rooted in the commercialization model? (73)

  3. Explain the consequences of identifying “capitalism” with “cities”. (73-74)

  4. Does the emergence of capitalism bear a relationship with development in commercial sophistication, science, and technology? (75)

  5. Was the autonomy of the cities a decisive factor in the emergence of capitalism?

  6. What was the critical factor in the emergence of capitalism? (75-76)

  7. Explain the logic of trade, according to the author (76-77)

  8. Explain the difference between “profit-seeking” and “efficient” production. (77)

  9. Do the “profits deriving from the advantages in the process of circulation” belong to the capitalist logic? Why? (or, why not?) (79)

  10. Explain the “non-capitalist modes of exploitation” (79-80)

  11. Why was the trade in grain (page 80-82) conducted according to the principles of pre-capitalist commerce?

  12. Explain the productive models of Florence and the Dutch Republic. Why did they not give place to a capitalist system? (87-94)

Sunday, March 7, 2021

Meiksins Wood: Chapter 3

 Reading guide for The Origin of Capitalism. A Longer View. Meiksins Wood. 

Chapter 3: “Marxist Alternatives”. 


  1. What is left unexplained by the transition debate?

  2. Did Brenner accept the existence of a “proto-capitalism”? Explain Why. 

  3. What is the “dynamic internal to feudalism” that Brenner searched for?

  4. Why does he explain this dynamic in terms of lords and peasants? Analyze the importance of the concept of reproduction in his argument. (52)

  5. Explain the relationship between landlords and tenants in England, according to Brenner. (52-53) 

  6.  Explain the “rules for reproduction”, according to Brenner. Why do they create a new historical dynamic? (53)

  7.  Explain the difference, in the text, between “compulsion” and “opportunity”. Put these concepts in the context of the “commercialization model”. (54)

  8. Explain the notion of “extra-economic forms of surplus extraction”. Why, in capitalism, surplus extraction is purely economic? (55-56)

  9. Why, in Brenner, it is class relations that explains the rise of capitalism? (58)

  10. Explain the whole process of subjection to market imperatives, on page 60. 

  11. Why does this process cause proletarianization? (60)

  12. Why did England transmit capitalism to the rest of Europe (and, eventually, to the rest of the world?

  13. Explain the transformation of the concept of “market”: from a familiar, physical place, into a mechanism beyond communal control, self-regulating, opaque, etc. (69).

Sunday, February 28, 2021

Meiksins Wood: Download link

 You can find the book by clicking on this LINK

Reading guide for The Origin of Capitalism. A Longer View. Meiksins Wood.

 Reading guide for The Origin of Capitalism. A Longer View. Meiksins Wood. 

Chapter 2: “Marxist Debates”. 


  1. Why does the author speak about the old models of capitalism as a paradoxical blend of transhistorical determinism and free market voluntarism?

  2. What is the model (antithetical to the old models) that the author is searching for? How does she define it? 

  3. Explain Marx’s two different narratives about the origins of capitalism. 

  4. Explain the “commercialization model” (page 35). 

  5. Explain why, in the commercialization model, capitalism is just a quantitative expansion of commerce and wealth. 

  6. What transformed wealth into capital, according to Marx? And why? (page 36). 

  7. Where did capitalism begin, according to Marx? 

  8. What is the central question posed by Sweezy and Dobbs about the transition from feudalism to capitalism?

  9. Dobb and Hilton explain this transition in terms of a “liberation of petty commodity producers from feudal exploitation”: does this explanation belong to the commercialization model or not? Why?

  10. What is, for Sweezy, the reason for the transition from feudalism to capitalism? (page 40). 

  11. What does Sweezy say about the inability of the ruling class to maintain control over the labor power? 

  12. Explain the idea of capitalism as an economic model already present in the simple commodity production (42). 

  13. What is “serfdom” according to Perry Anderson? 

  14. Where is the “new economic sphere”, not controlled by aristocracy, according to Perry Anderson? 

  15. What is “absolutism”, according to Anderson? Why does it fracture the unity that characterized the feudal system? 

  16. Is Anderson’s explanation about the origin of capitalism compatible with the commercialization model? Explain.

Sunday, February 21, 2021

Kurz - Reading guide.

 Reading guide for “Classical Political Economy” - Kurz. 


  1. Explain the difference between Classical Economy and Marginalist Economy (pages 19-20)

  2. The author says that classical economists have an “objectivist point of view”. Why? (page 19). 

  3. Why do the issues of socio-economic reproduction and development assume centre stage in the analysis of classical political economy? (page 20).

  4. The systemic and general approach is “dynamic”. Why? (page 20).

  5. Why the author relates the marginalist approach to “robinsonades”? (page 20). 

  6. Explain the methodological individualism of the marginalist approach (page 20). 

  7. According to the author, if we only have autarchic units of production and consumption, then, there is no society. Do you agree with this opinion? (page 21).

  8. Explain the place of Sociology between “Political Economy” and “Economics” (page 21). 

  9. Explain the position of Auguste Compte against Political economy.

  10. With marginalism, sociological themes were removed from the economic discourse. Why? (page 22). 

  11. Explain David Hume’s naturalistic view of man (page 22). 

  12. What is Adam Smith’s view of moral judgment? (page 22)

  13. What is the main theme of Smith’s Wealth of Nations? (page 23)

  14. What is the role of the concepts of cooperation and assistance in Smith’s scheme? (page 23)

  15. Explain the two crucial axioms in Smith’s scheme (page 24). 

  16. Explain the three characteristics of Smith’s economic agent (24).

  17. Explain the “three grand orders of men”, or social classes, according to the classical economists (page 24). 

  18. Explain the differences in the access to information and knowledge, according to the social class (pages 24-25). 

  19. Why does asymmetric information give rise to a moral hazard (page 26). 

  20. Explain the process of adverse selection of debtors by the banks, in Smith’s scheme (page 26). 

  21. Explain the opposition between the cleverness of legislators and the cunning of business people (page 27).

Final Presentation - Topics

Final Presentation.  Topics:    Meiksins Wood’s critique of the “commercialization model”.    The relationship between landlords and tenants...