Sunday, March 20, 2022

Final Presentation - Topics

Final Presentation. 

Topics: 

 

  1. Meiksins Wood’s critique of the “commercialization model”. 

 

  1. The relationship between landlords and tenants, according to 

Brenner. (Also: “new rules for reproduction”). Why do they create 

a new historical dynamic? (Meiksins Wood: 51-55)

 

  1. Brenner: Subjection to market imperatives; the difference between 

“compulsion” and “opportunity”; purely economic surplus 

extraction.  

  1. Why did England transmit capitalism to the rest of Europe

 (and, eventually, to the rest of the world?)  

  1. Commerce - Capitalism. 

  1. French absolutism - British capitalism. 

        7. Marx’s concept of “estrangement”.  

  1. The debate Keynes-von Hayek.

Piketty

 


Hayek

 



The Shock Doctrine

 


Sunday, March 13, 2022

Mid-term

 

Introduction to Political Economy. Midterm Exam. 


Class: MONDAYS, from 8: 30 to 11: 30 AM. 


Policies:  


Deadline: March, Saturday 19, 2022, at 23H 59m. (11:59 PM.)


(BUT Please, try to start working on this essay as soon as

you can.)


You have to send your work via e-mail at upecenglish100@gmail.com 


Please send your document in WORD format. 

No other format will be accepted. 


Recommendations: 

 

The exam is INDIVIDUAL. One student=One exam 

(no work in groups is allowed at this point). 


Avoid writing the same exam with your classmate:

 If I receive 2 or more exams that look exactly the same 

(or even very similar), both exams will be graded with a 0.


The basic source for your work must be Meiksins Wood’s 

book, The origin of Capitalism.

You can also use other sources. Every quoted book has 

to be listed in your Bibliography. 


Avoid long quotations from the book: the phrasing 

(the construction of the argument) has to be yours. 

It has to be very clear when you are quoting, and when you 

are giving your own opinion. Your basic source must be the 

textbook used in class. Quotations must mention the page

 following the model: 


“Enclosure continued to be a major source of conflict in Early

Modern England” (Meiksins Wood 2017, 109). 


(In this quotation, the text between quotation marks has to be 

exactly the same text we can read in page 109 of Meiksins 

Wood’s book. We cannot change even a comma.)


Each quotation should not go beyond 3-4 lines: You have to 

demonstrate that you are able to control the text, to explain 

its components. In conclusion, you have to build your own 

argument. 


Take a look at the Rubric: it explains in detail how 

your exam is going to be evaluated. 


Extension: Between 3 and 5 pages 

(Times New Roman 12, double spaced). 


Avoid plagiarism: Your essay will be checked online. 

If your text shows 15% (or more) of coincidence with 

something previously 

written, your grade will be a 0 (zero). 


Question: Explain the emergence of Capitalism, according 

to Meiksins Wood. Explain the main components of the 

concept: the agrarian context in Britain, the property of 

the land, the commodification of the workforce, the 

market imperatives. Explain the interrelations between 

all these concepts. Explain why this concept of “capitalism”, 

offered by the author, opposes the “commercialization model”.


The political theory of John Meynard Keynes

The Political Theory of John Maynard Keynes.


 

  1. What are the three explanations for unemployment 

given by Classical Economics?

  1. How does the “free market” establish an equilibrium 

between the supply of labor and the demand of labor? 

  1. What is the historical context of Keynes’ theory? Is there 

something new that Classical Economics cannot explain?

  1. What is the real reason for unemployment, according to 

Keynes?

  1. How will the demand for goods recover, according to 

classical theory?

  1. (And, according to Keynes?)

  2. How must the State react to an economic crisis?

  3. Explain the “Multiplier Effect”. 

  4. Explain, briefly, the neo-liberal critique of Keynes’ 

theory (Friedman, Hayek).  



The crack of 1929

 Debate: 

 

  1. What are the main causes of the stock market crash?

  2. What was the Great Depression? 

  3. Analyze unemployment and its consequences.




Video 1 - The Stock Market

 

You will find a very basic explanation about the stock market in this video. 




Tuesday, April 13, 2021

Chapter: “Estranged Labor” (p. 69-84). Questions.

 Marx. Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844. 

Chapter: “Estranged Labor” (p. 69-84). 



  1. Entäußerung - Entfremdung.  Read the definitions in pages 10-11, and explain them. 

  2. Why does the worker sink to the level of commodity? (the most wretched of commodities, indeed). 

  3. Why, for Marx, the necessary result of competition is monopoly? Do you agree with his idea?

  4. What is the difference between the classical political economy’s approach and Marx’s approach regarding private property?

  5. “It [Political economy] takes the interest of the capitalist to be the ultimate cause” (70). How should this evolve, according to Marx?

  6. Should Political economy criticize competition and avarice? What is, concretely, the Marxist turn in regards to the previous authors (Smith, for example)?

  7. Political economy does not grasp the connections between private property, avarice, and the separation of labor, capital, and landed property. Why should we not explain all these divisions by going back to a fictitious primordial condition?  

  8. Explain: “Labor produces not only commodities: it produces itself and the worker as a commodity” (71). 

  9. Explain why labor is a power independent of the producer (71). 

  10. Labor has been congealed in an object. (Labor’s realization-objectification). Why does Marx speak about a “loss of reality” for the worker? Explain. 

  11. Explain: “The worker is related to the product of his labor as to an alien object” (71)

  12. Why does Marx say that the worker creates an alien objective world over-against himself? (72)

  13. Explain: “[H]is [the worker’s] labor becomes an object, an external existence…it becomes a power on its own, confronting him” (72). 

  14. Why does the worker become a slave of his object?

  15. Explain the critique: “Political economy conceals the estrangement inherent in the nature of labor by not considering the direct relationship between the worker (labor) and production.

  16. The relation of the worker to production is the essential relationship of labor. Why?

  17. Not only the product is estranging. The very act of production is estranging as well. Production itself is active alienation. Explain. (73-74)

………………………………………………………………………..

Synthesis: a) The product of labor is strange to the worker.

     b) The act of production is strange to the worker. 

………………………………………………………………………..

  1. “Labor is external to the worker”. Explain why the worker only feels himself outside his work. 

  2. Why is the worker reduced to his animal functions? Explain (74). 


  1. Explain: “The universality of man is in practice manifested precisely in the universality which makes all nature his inorganic body” (75-6)

  2. Explain the difference between Man and Animal (according to Marx).

  3. Explain: “[Animal] produces one-sidedly, while man produces universally” (77). 

  4.  Why does nature appear as man’s work, as man’s reality? Explain.

……………………………………..

Synthesis. The object of labor is the objectification of man’s species life. Man duplicates himself not only intellectually, but actively as well.

But estranged labor transforms man's species life into a means to his physical existence.

Then, we have: 

c) Man is an alien to himself.

d) Man is an alien to other man. 

……………………………………….

  1. Explain point C.

  2. Explain point D.

  3. To whom does the product of labor belong?

  4. Define private property, according to Marx

  5. Explain Marx’s critique against Proudhon (81-2)

  6. Explain Marx’s notion of “universal emancipation”.

Video - Questions.

 


  1. “Labour produces not only commodities; it produces itself and the worker as a commodity”. (Why?)

  2. From Hegel to Marx: from Idealism to Materialism. 

  3. We need a change, but not a change in ideas. We need a change in the means of production. 

  4. Relate the concept of “alienation from the product of labor” to Adam Smith’s concept of “division of labor”. (7: 00)

  5. For Adam Smith, the individual is the atom of society. Do you think that society can be thought of as an addition of atoms? 

  6. Did you stop artificial consumption due to the pandemics?

Alienation in Capitalism: Marx.

 



Monday, April 5, 2021

Adam Smith

 


Discussion: Adam Smith. 


  1. “Working people would be unemployed” (Part 1). 

  2. “Governments should not interfere” (Part 2). 

  3. About infrastructure (Part 2).

  4. Taxes. A wealth tax (Part 2).

Sunday, March 28, 2021

Meiksins Wood. Chapter 5: “The Agrarian Origin of Capitalism”

 Reading guide for The Origin of Capitalism. A Longer View. Meiksins Wood.

Chapter 5: “The Agrarian Origin of Capitalism”


  1. Explain the process of appropriation of the surplus by exploiters, according to Marx. (95) 

  2. Explain the French structure of exploitation: absolutism. (96)

  3. Why, in the capitalist model, we cannot speak of “direct coercion”? (96)

  4. Define capitalism in this context. (97)

  5. Explain the capitalist logic of imperatives. (97) 

  6. Why is the capitalist system in permanent expansion? (97)

  7. Enumerate and explain the main characteristics of England (the “European exception): -State; Infrastructure and communications; London at the center of the national market. (98-99)  

  8. Explain the relation between landlords and tenants. Why did it give origin to what the author calls “competitive production”? (100)

  9. Explain the difference between market rent and customary rent. (101)

  10. What was the situation in France in regards to property rights? (102)

  11. Explain the relationship between a highly productive agriculture and the large wage-labour force in England. (103)

  12. Explain the concepts of improvement and improver in the English agrarian context. (106)

  13. Why did the traditional concepts of land property start being debated at the time? 

  14. Explain the notion of enclosure in the context of the 17th century in England. (108-9)

  15. Explain John Locke’s opinion about unoccupied land (in the context of the theorization of capitalist property). (110). 

  16. Why does the author say that Locke justifies colonial expropriation? (112)

  17. Why does the author say that, according to Locke, the master appropriates the labour of his servant?

  18. Why are the employers of labour called producers, if, in fact, the producers are the workers? (112-3)

  19.  Why does the author say that Locke gives us a theory of property based on capitalist principles?

  20. Connect Locke’s ideas with the notion of private property. (115)

  21. Why does Locke, according to the author, justify slavery? (115)

  22. What is the bourgeois revolution? (118)

Sunday, March 21, 2021

Meiksins Wood. Chapter 4: “Commerce or Capitalism?”

 Reading guide for The Origin of Capitalism. A Longer View. Meiksins Wood. 

Chapter 4: “Commerce or Capitalism?”


  1. Why should the transition from feudalism to capitalism not be treated as a general European process? (73)

  2. Why is this treatment rooted in the commercialization model? (73)

  3. Explain the consequences of identifying “capitalism” with “cities”. (73-74)

  4. Does the emergence of capitalism bear a relationship with development in commercial sophistication, science, and technology? (75)

  5. Was the autonomy of the cities a decisive factor in the emergence of capitalism?

  6. What was the critical factor in the emergence of capitalism? (75-76)

  7. Explain the logic of trade, according to the author (76-77)

  8. Explain the difference between “profit-seeking” and “efficient” production. (77)

  9. Do the “profits deriving from the advantages in the process of circulation” belong to the capitalist logic? Why? (or, why not?) (79)

  10. Explain the “non-capitalist modes of exploitation” (79-80)

  11. Why was the trade in grain (page 80-82) conducted according to the principles of pre-capitalist commerce?

  12. Explain the productive models of Florence and the Dutch Republic. Why did they not give place to a capitalist system? (87-94)

Sunday, March 7, 2021

Meiksins Wood: Chapter 3

 Reading guide for The Origin of Capitalism. A Longer View. Meiksins Wood. 

Chapter 3: “Marxist Alternatives”. 


  1. What is left unexplained by the transition debate?

  2. Did Brenner accept the existence of a “proto-capitalism”? Explain Why. 

  3. What is the “dynamic internal to feudalism” that Brenner searched for?

  4. Why does he explain this dynamic in terms of lords and peasants? Analyze the importance of the concept of reproduction in his argument. (52)

  5. Explain the relationship between landlords and tenants in England, according to Brenner. (52-53) 

  6.  Explain the “rules for reproduction”, according to Brenner. Why do they create a new historical dynamic? (53)

  7.  Explain the difference, in the text, between “compulsion” and “opportunity”. Put these concepts in the context of the “commercialization model”. (54)

  8. Explain the notion of “extra-economic forms of surplus extraction”. Why, in capitalism, surplus extraction is purely economic? (55-56)

  9. Why, in Brenner, it is class relations that explains the rise of capitalism? (58)

  10. Explain the whole process of subjection to market imperatives, on page 60. 

  11. Why does this process cause proletarianization? (60)

  12. Why did England transmit capitalism to the rest of Europe (and, eventually, to the rest of the world?

  13. Explain the transformation of the concept of “market”: from a familiar, physical place, into a mechanism beyond communal control, self-regulating, opaque, etc. (69).

Final Presentation - Topics

Final Presentation.  Topics:    Meiksins Wood’s critique of the “commercialization model”.    The relationship between landlords and tenants...